„Military men are "dumb, stupid animals to be used" as pawns for foreign policy.“

Kissinger has denied saying it.
The only evidence that Kissinger ever said this was a claim in the book, The Final Days, by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, in chapter 14 (p.194 in the 1995 paperback edition). Woodward & Bernstein claimed that one of Kissinger's political foes, Alexander Haig, had told someone unnamed, that he (Haig) had heard Kissinger say it. That's triple hearsay, made even weaker by the fact that one of the parties is anonymous. Kissinger has denied ever saying it, and it was never substantiated by Haig, nor by anyone of known identity who claimed to have heard it. As Kirkus Reviews noted about the whole book, "none of it is substantiated in any assessable way."
In fact, the quote is not even very plausible, on its face. Kissinger served with distinction in the U.S. Army during WWII, and was awarded the Bronze Star. He has always been very respectful of other servicemen and their sacrifices. For him to have said such a thing would have been wildly out of character. In fact, the awkward phrasing doesn't even sound like Kissinger, whose English prose is consistently measured and careful, despite his heavy accent, even when he speaks extemporaneously.

Última atualização 22 de Maio de 2020. História

Citações relacionadas

Bob Woodward photo
Orson Scott Card photo

„Only stupid men trying to seem smart need to be with dumb women. Only weak men trying to look strong are attracted to compliant women.“

—  Orson Scott Card, Ender's Game hexalogy

Page 96
Ender's Game series, First Meetings in the Enderverse (2003), Teacher's Pest
Fonte: First Meetings in Ender's Universe

Ilana Mercer photo

„A bully's universe: US foreign policy operates upon the premise that American men and matériel should be capable of reaching and controlling all corners of the world.“

—  Ilana Mercer South African writer

“Putin Saves Us From Ourselves,” http://www.ilanamercer.com/phprunner/public_article_list_view.php?editid1=644 WorldNetDaily.com, March 23, 2012.
2010s, 2012

Andrei Grechko photo

„For us military men, it is impossible to forget.“

—  Andrei Grechko Soviet military commander 1903 - 1976

Quoted in "Bulletin" - by Cold War International History Project, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars - Cold War - 1995

„It is a sensible military tactic to recognize the enemy before you shoot. The common enemy is the animality in man, and not the men here and there who are behaving like animals at the moment.“

—  Milton Mayer American journalist 1908 - 1986

I Think I'll Sit This One Out (1939)
Contexto: It is a sensible military tactic to recognize the enemy before you shoot. The common enemy is the animality in man, and not the men here and there who are behaving like animals at the moment. Neither science nor prayer nor force will save us. What will save us is the reason that enables men, in ancient Israel and modern America, to choose between guns and butter, and to choose well. When we have produced men of reason, we shall have a world of reason, and the Hitlers will disappear. As long as we produce men of force we shall have a world of force, and the Hitlers, whoever wins the wars, will carry the day.
Society may make many demands on me, as long as it keeps me out of the cave. It may take my property. It may take my life. But when it puts me back into the cave I must say, politely but firmly, to hell with society. My ancestors were cannibals without benefit of parliaments.

Mark Twain photo
Isaac Asimov photo

„The military mind remains unparalleled as a vehicle of creative stupidity.“

—  Isaac Asimov, livro In Memory Yet Green

In Memory Yet Green (1979), p. 461
General sources

George Colman the Younger photo

„On their own merits modest men are dumb.“

—  George Colman the Younger English dramatist and writer 1762 - 1836

Epilogue to the Heir at Law, reported in Bartlett's Familiar Quotations, 10th ed. (1919).

Anna Sewell photo
Woody Harrelson photo

„Because superior non-animal methods are used for this exact training by military and civilian programs around the world, animals are clearly not required to meet your objectives. … I'm sure you agree that our military personnel deserve state-of-the-art training and that our country deserves to be respected for its civilized treatment of animals.“

—  Woody Harrelson American actor 1961

Letter that he sent to the Army, against the use of monkeys in chemical attack training exercises; full text in "Woody Harrelson Fights Army Tests on Chimps", in Usnews.com (13 September 2011) https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/washington-whispers/2011/09/13/woody-harrelson-fights-army-tests-on-chimps.

F. Scott Fitzgerald photo
Edward Abbey photo
Ralph Klein photo
Jackie Collins photo
TotalBiscuit photo
Jesse Ventura photo

„The current use of the National Guard is wrong… These are men who did not sign up to go occupy foreign nations.“

—  Jesse Ventura American politician and former professional wrestler 1951

The Army Times (6 September 2004) http://www.armytimes.com/story.php?f=1-ARMYPAPER-323322.php

Jack London photo

„Intelligent men are cruel. Stupid men are monstrously cruel.“

—  Jack London, livro The Star Rover

The Star Rover
Variante: Intelligent men are cruel. Stupid men are monstrously cruel

Kurt Vonnegut photo
George Carlin photo

„Here's all you have to know about men and women: women are crazy, men are stupid. And the main reason women are crazy is that men are stupid.“

—  George Carlin American stand-up comedian 1937 - 2008

Books, When Will Jesus Bring the Pork Chops? (2004)
Fonte: When Will Jesus Bring The Pork Chops?