„I claimed that "individualist anarchism and communist anarchism are the same, or nearly so, in terms of moral motivations and ultimate goals".“

— Errico Malatesta, Context: I claimed that "individualist anarchism and communist anarchism are the same, or nearly so, in terms of moral motivations and ultimate goals". I know that one could counter my claim with hundreds of texts and plenty of deeds of self-proclaimed individualist anarchists, which would demonstrate that individualist anarchist and communist anarchist are separated by something of a moral abyss. However, I deny that that kind of individualists can be included among anarchists, despite their liking for calling themselves so. If anarchy means non-government, non-domination, non-oppression by man over man, how can one call himself anarchist without lying to himself and the others, when he frankly claims that he would oppress the others for the satisfaction of his Ego, without any scruple or limit, other than that drawn by his own strength? He can be a rebel, because he is being oppressed and he fights to become an oppressor, as other nobler rebels fight to destroy any kind of oppression; but he sure cannot be anarchist. He is a would-be bourgeois, a would-be tyrant, who is unable to accomplish his dreams of dominion and wealth by his own strength and by legal means, and therefore he approaches anarchists to exploit their moral and material solidarity. Therefore, I think the question is not about "communists" and "individualists", but rather about anarchists and non-anarchists. And we, or at least many of us, were quite wrong in discussing a certain kind of alleged "anarchist individualism" as if it really was one of the various tendencies of anarchism, instead of fighting it as one of the many disguises of authoritarianism.

Errico Malatesta photo
Errico Malatesta
1853 - 1932
Publicidade

Citações relacionadas

Edward Abbey photo
Emma Goldman photo
Publicidade
Masanobu Fukuoka photo
 Archimedes photo
Henrietta Swan Leavitt photo
Gene Roddenberry photo
Bob Marley photo

„I know that I'm not perfect and that I don't claim to be,
so before you point your fingers make sure your hands are clean.“

— Bob Marley Jamaican singer, songwriter, musician 1945 - 1981
Context: Who are you to judge the life I live? I know that I'm not perfect and that I don't claim to be, so before you point your fingers make sure your hands are clean. Could you be loved

Osip Mandelstam photo

„Only in Russia poetry is respected – it gets people killed. Is there anywhere else where poetry is so common a motive for murder?“

— Osip Mandelstam Russian poet and essayist 1891 - 1938
Quoted in Nadezhda Mandelstam, Hope Against Hope: A Memoir (1970), ch. 35

Publicidade
Imre Kertész photo
Vladimir Lenin photo

„The goal of Socialism is Communism.“

— Vladimir Lenin Russian politician, led the October Revolution 1870 - 1924

 Ali photo
Steven Pinker photo
Publicidade
Paul Tillich photo

„Faith is the state of being ultimately concerned.“

— Paul Tillich German-American theologian and philosopher 1886 - 1965
Context: Faith is the state of being ultimately concerned. The content matters infinitely for the life of the believer, but it does not matter for the formal definition of faith. And this is the first step we have to make in order to understand the dynamics of faith.

Michael Jackson photo
Hannah Arendt photo
Próximo